The overprescribing of opioid-based painkillers may be the main, but not sole, driver of the increased abuse of opioids in rural America.
Economists say that other factors, including declining farm income, extreme weather, and other natural disasters, may affect this crisis that is killing thousands of citizens and costing the country billions of dollars.
In a study of relationships among socioeconomic variables and opioid-related drug overdoses, researchers found several correlations that don’t often come up in the current conversation about the nation’s deaths of despair, which include opioid overdoses, says Stephan Goetz, professor of agricultural and regional economics at Penn State and director of the Northeast Regional Center for Rural Development.
For example, a higher number of natural disasters experienced historically in a county is correlated with an increase in opioid overdoses, according to the researchers. They used presidentially declared disasters by county from FEMA (the Federal Emergency Management Agency) to determine the effect of natural disasters on opioid deaths. These disasters primarily include weather-related events, such as hurricanes, droughts, and floods.
If climatologists’ warnings are correct, a changing climate could produce more extreme weather patterns, which could then have an effect on opioid overdoses and deaths, says Goetz, who worked with Meri Davlasheridze, assistant professor in marine sciences at Texas A&M at Galveston.
Income also matters, according to the researchers. For each $10,000 reduction in net income per farm, opioid overdoses rose by 10 percent from a national average of 10.2 deaths per 100,000 people to 11.2 deaths per 100,000 people. Opioid-related deaths are also increasing in rural counties, they add.
“Our results confirm that economic factors, including income especially and unemployment, as well as population density—or rurality—are important,” says Goetz. “As we are controlling for economic factors, population density appears to play an independent role in accounting for the disparate death rates.”
Scope of the crisis
Goetz adds that it is important to use caution when interpreting this data.
“We are giving each county the same weight in our statistical analysis and the farming population is not that big—it’s about one or two percent of the US population,” says Goetz. “But, there could be a spillover effect—if the farm income declines, the rest of the rural economy suffers.”
Estimates indicate that opioid-related drug overdoses cost the country $432 billion in 2015, according to the researchers, who presented their findings at a recent meeting of the Allied Social Sciences Association annual meeting in Philadelphia.
“To give some sense of this, the opioid crisis is a problem that is orders of magnitude larger than the costs associated with weather-related disasters in 2017,” says Goetz. “This is a far-reaching problem—and it cuts across social, economic, and political lines.”
Signs of hope
There are some glimmers of hope in the research, Goetz says. For example, overdoses among younger people seem to be declining, Goetz says. The highest rates of overdose are among people in the 45- to 64-year-old range.
Because the self-employed have lower rates of overdose, the researchers suggest that self-employment also seems to be a deterrent against the opioid crisis.
“Sometimes we think of the self-employed, or entrepreneurs as more stressed and as people who might be looking for an escape from those pressures, but that doesn’t appear to be the case in opioid use,” says Goetz.
The researchers theorize that one reason this wave of opioid deaths may be higher in rural counties is because of the low number of mental-health treatment facilities in those areas and, perhaps, the stigma attached to seeking help in those facilities.
“There are far fewer mental-health treatment facilities, so if you have a problem, you might not know where to go for help,” Goetz says. “We’re thinking that one of the things we need to investigate in the future is whether awareness is the problem or is there a stigma? These are all important issues to consider and they could be addressed through educational or other programs.”